One of our staff members is contributing considerably to a News Archiving service at Mu. Any well educated (Masters, PhD or above) users who wish to make comments on news sites, please contact Jim Burton directly rather than using this list, and we can work on maximising view count.
Template:Debate Guide:Arguments about adult-minor relationships: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
The Admins (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Jim Burton (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: "Stranger danger" or "It could be anyone"|"Stranger danger" or "It could be anyone"]] - Two conflicting "expert" opinions (both unfounded, abused to incite fear). | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: "Stranger danger" or "It could be anyone"|"Stranger danger" or "It could be anyone"]] - Two conflicting "expert" opinions (both unfounded, abused to incite fear). | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: If we could only save one child|If we could only save one child]] - Negative utilitarianism is discredited and nonsensical meta-ethics. | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: If we could only save one child|If we could only save one child]] - Negative utilitarianism is discredited and nonsensical meta-ethics. | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Child sexualisation and objectification|Sexualisation and objectification]] - Sex/physical relationships needn't be all-consuming . | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Child sexualisation and objectification|Sexualisation and objectification]] - Sex/physical relationships needn't be all-consuming. | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Sexual inexperience|Sexual inexperience]] - When is supposedly the "best time" to gain life experience? | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Sexual inexperience|Sexual inexperience]] - When is supposedly the "best time" to gain life experience? | ||
*''Against'': [[Debate Guide: Teacher-Student Sex|Teacher/student sex]] - The contention these relations are always ethically wrong. | |||
[[File:Gnhgdfsgrfrs.png|150px|link=|frameless|right]] | [[File:Gnhgdfsgrfrs.png|150px|link=|frameless|right]] | ||
'''Levels of harm are exaggerated and the sources are completely misunderstood...''' | '''Levels of harm are exaggerated and the sources are completely misunderstood...''' | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Power disparity|Power disparity/Stockholm Syndrome]] - Differences in power | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Power disparity|Power disparity/Stockholm Syndrome]] - Differences in power may lead to abuse, but how often is this actually the case? | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Profound and lifelong scarring|Profound and lifelong scarring]] - These | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Profound and lifelong scarring|Profound and lifelong scarring]] - These sequelae are thankfully rare. | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Doomed from the beginning|Doomed from the beginning]] - Will adult-minor relationships really die off as the youngster grows older? | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Doomed from the beginning|Doomed from the beginning]] - Will adult-minor relationships really die off as the youngster grows older? | ||
*''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Recidivism is highest among child sex offenders|Recidivism is highest among child sex offenders]] - Demonstrably false. | *''Against:'' [[Debate Guide: Recidivism is highest among child sex offenders|Recidivism is highest among child sex offenders]] - Demonstrably false. | ||
| Line 26: | Line 27: | ||
*[[Debate Guide: Nonhuman relatives|Nonhuman relatives]] - Other species' adult-juvenile sexuality. | *[[Debate Guide: Nonhuman relatives|Nonhuman relatives]] - Other species' adult-juvenile sexuality. | ||
*[[Debate Guide: Historical nonadult-adult sex|Historical nonadult-adult sex]] - Historical | *[[Debate Guide: Historical nonadult-adult sex|Historical nonadult-adult sex]] - Historical societies in which said relations were permitted. | ||
'''Many people also speak from direct experience...''' | '''Many people also speak from direct experience...''' | ||
*[[Accounts and Testimonies|Our database of accounts]] - An anecdotal study, including useful infographics. | *[[Accounts and Testimonies|Our database of accounts]] - An anecdotal study, including useful infographics. | ||
Latest revision as of 23:31, 14 September 2025
Age of Consent laws are a blunt instrument...
- Against: It's wrong because it's illegal - Homosexuality was once illegal.
- Problems with the Age of Consent - There are numerous flaws, listed on this page.
- Against: Legal pragmatism - It is wrongly argued that high Ages of Consent are "pragmatic".
- Against: There is no law that prohibits minors - Nonsensical argument claiming minors are already sexually emancipated.
Myths and bad meta-ethics plague discussions of expressed adult-minor sexuality...
- Against: All child molesters are pedophiles - This belief is demonstrably false.
- Against: "Stranger danger" or "It could be anyone" - Two conflicting "expert" opinions (both unfounded, abused to incite fear).
- Against: If we could only save one child - Negative utilitarianism is discredited and nonsensical meta-ethics.
- Against: Sexualisation and objectification - Sex/physical relationships needn't be all-consuming.
- Against: Sexual inexperience - When is supposedly the "best time" to gain life experience?
- Against: Teacher/student sex - The contention these relations are always ethically wrong.
Levels of harm are exaggerated and the sources are completely misunderstood...
- Against: Power disparity/Stockholm Syndrome - Differences in power may lead to abuse, but how often is this actually the case?
- Against: Profound and lifelong scarring - These sequelae are thankfully rare.
- Against: Doomed from the beginning - Will adult-minor relationships really die off as the youngster grows older?
- Against: Recidivism is highest among child sex offenders - Demonstrably false.
Other societies and species are points of interest...
- Nonhuman relatives - Other species' adult-juvenile sexuality.
- Historical nonadult-adult sex - Historical societies in which said relations were permitted.
Many people also speak from direct experience...
- Our database of accounts - An anecdotal study, including useful infographics.