Debate Guide: Doomed from the beginning
As soon as the young person grows beyond their partner's age of attraction, the relationship will break down.
Even if this were correct, compliance with a romantic norm is not a justification for arbitrarily condemning or denying any "sexual" relations within a certain (as yet undefined) age range. There has been a trend in society towards casual connections, and this argument completely ignores that.
Lack of interest in aging minds and bodies is also nothing new. If every relationship which eventually broke down were a terrible injustice and abomination, we would be judging and intervening in a lot of adult-adult relationships. This includes relationships between older and younger adults, where rather unsurprisingly, it tends to be the younger partner who ends the relationship.[1]
On the topic of adult-adult relationships, research by Justin Lehmiller and Christopher Agnew in 2011 has revealed that age gap relationships in which the husband was older, were related to better life satisfaction for both partners. Their research also suggests such partners tend to be more trusting, less jealous, and less selfish compared to persons similar in age to their partners.[2]
The basis of the argument is flawed, regardless
Regardless of the ethical questions, the idea of a fundamental, fatal flaw rooted in the "time-sensitive" nature of chronophilia is a non-starter for a number of reasons. Not only can those who prefer adults fall in love with minors, but actual MAPs have a range of attractions. For a starter, MAPs are more typically nonexclusive than teleiophiles,[3] experiencing secondary attractions that often span upwards into adulthood. So in fact, the older partner's affinity for the minor may grow or at least persist, if their attraction to younger people is not exclusive. And since most people with some form of pedophilia are preferentially teleiophilic and most preferential pedophiles are non-exclusive, this kind of evolving long-term relationship would likely be common.
There is also the possibility that in the absence of mutual sexual attraction, a relationship may continue along existing lines of pedagogy/tuition, platonic love, or any other form of care, mentorship or support. Even if this is not possible, "break-ups" are sometimes constructive life decisions - often insisted upon by the younger partner, leaving them with the skills and confidence to pursue renewed goals in life.
External links
- Love Across Ages: The Conscious Craft of Age-Gap Relationships - Julie Harris.
References
- ↑ Psych Central - Older Man Younger Woman Relationships
- ↑ May-December Paradoxes: An Exploration of Age-Gap Relationships in Western Society. Lehmiller and Agnew (2011).
- ↑ Blanchard, R., Kuban, M.E., Blak, T. et al. Sexual Attraction to Others: A Comparison of Two Models of Alloerotic Responding in Men. Arch Sex Behav 41, 13–29 (2012).