23 Sep, 2024: Our collection of material documenting harassment, doxing and allegations of illegal behavior against MAPs, on the part of a purportedly "MAP" group, is now complete. A second article documenting a campaign of disinformation by said group is nearing completion, and will be shared here.

Special Article: Anti-c MAP Tumblr, Twitter and Fediverse - Material for Character Analysis

From NewgonWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This article has been published and promoted after a supposed "MAP" website editor joined a Matrix chat room (PCMA) in violation of its conditions and subsequently posted screen-caps of multiple individuals without their consent, including those experiencing mental health problems and legal difficulties: map-wiki.com/index.php/Newgon/Records. The material documented here concerns the individuals (Iris, Lecter) responsible for said article, and includes others for balance.

Our article documents screen-caps from anti-contact and some neutral-c pediverse spaces for the purpose of present and future character analysis. We have only constructed detailed profiles of individuals who have been accused of malicious behavior, intending to determine the validity, or otherwise of those claims. We do not publish any information that may be personally identifying.

For more detailed profiling of some parties covered in this article, see the claims/character analysis article.

Malicious or illegal behavior indicated

Early Pediverse has suffered from occasional malicious incidents. Owing to the wild-west style of federated social networks, where anybody can set up a server, this behavior has sometimes been tolerated and perpetuated by instance owners. This has led some to call for professionalization, co-operativization, or higher levels of accountability in instance leadership, or the outright redaction of particular servers by way of defederation or suspension of domain. Domain suspensions put paid to the well-known, 1000+ user servers, Lolison and Childlove.space, and seriously damaged Youjo.love.

Iris [NNIA]

Chronic, or Iris, a member of the NNIA fediverse instance and MAP Wiki editor, has a long history of doxing MAPs and consorting with pedophile hunters. A plural system and zoosadist MAP with "it" pronouns, their behavior has been tolerated by the instance admin, Lecter. This most likely owes to compromising information held by Iris, one of Lecter's former online dates.

Iris is known to have imitated a pro-c MAP activist to enter PCMA, so it could then circulate selected chat logs via MAP Wiki, a site on which Lecter, below, is the administrator. Various individuals then contacted Newgon's Strategic Lead, Jim Burton about these events, some of which exposed sensitive information about legal struggles and mental health problems.

At the time of writing, Iris has not attempted to question the veracity of these screens. This is important, as they have a track record of changing their story suddenly.

Lecter [NNIA Admin]

MAP Wiki editor Lecter is the primary NNIA Admin (also a plural system and zoosadist) transmasc he/him. Lecter has been labelled by the person who got closest to him (Iris), as a reactionary, pro-c American who was born a male, endorses pedophile-hunting and sexually predates on "children" (see later section).

Lecter's activism is technically illegal[4] in his sometimes assumed home of Russia by virtue of LGBT/Pedophile propaganda censorship and community policing of pedophiles. His supposed Russian transmasculine identity is now doxed, yet he appears not to fear for his personal safety. As a result, we concur with PCMA server members who suggested an alternative location.[5] Lecter, however, is clearly competent in Russian.[6] This section focuses on more broadly malicious or illegal acts Lecter has definitely partaken of, admitted to or been accused of, and Iris's accusations will be covered later.

When we analyzed[7] the online activities of Lecter, we came to the conclusion that many of his problematic behaviors are downstream of, or dependent upon his relations with others, including Iris, who holds compromising information on him. Lecter is associated with the online paraphile community, known for its links to various fandoms, anti-fandoms, Zoosadist controversies and a range of truly disturbed individuals such as Zrcalo, all of whom are beyond the scope of this article. It is a sad fact that the sum effect of these online dramas has not been to improve the status of invalidated sexual minorities, and has instead emboldened harassers.

While we do not consider Lecter himself a deeply malicious individual, it is unfortunate our community has not been able to take action to reduce his influence.

The instance (NNIA) itself appears to be on top of illegal material, just like others are. Outliers such as users posting unredacted requests for illegal material had existed,[9] but did not seem common, nor religiously covered up, undermining the "grooming" accusations.[10]

Iris' claims Lecter is a born-male child predator and reactionary

A bizarre episode in 2021, saw Iris suddenly and viciously attack its closest ally, Lecter, releasing a document labeling him serial sexual predator in a frenzied act of political cannibalism. Iris, now close to adulthood, claims they hold compromising screenshots of their chats with Lecter. It is worth mentioning that such material would most likely be illegal, since Iris was a minor at the time. Their relationship with Lecter has "improved" since this file was shared.

The narrative presented here (if it is to be believed) strongly conflicts with Lecter's philosophical objections towards using deception and dishonest means to instigate controversies. See, for example, his "list of demands" made upon Newgon, which he repeated in 2024.

Confusingly, Newgon could not locate any denials or redactions of the claims made in the document from around the time, or more recently.

LoganTheACNOMAP [NNIA]

Another doxxing controversy involved Logan, a character closely associated with Iris, whose behavior was tolerated by Lecter.

We will publish screenshots when they become available.

No malicious or illegal behavior indicated

Expedient use of dishonesty

The below examples document evidence of admins and others using or supporting dishonest tactics for expedient reasons. Such actions may be seen as justifiable under some interpretations, and within their wider context.

Kay Faraday [FU Admin - former]

Kay Faraday, the former admin of the defunct freak.university (a highly successful neutral-c pediverse instance) has shared compromising information about and entertained the idea of doxing other MAPs. This was often in the context of humor and irony, but had caused concern within the community due to her position at the time.

At this point, she is not active in administrating Fediverse instances, and can probably be dismissed from any broader effort to hold Fediverse admins to account.

Jim Burton [Yesmap Matrix Admin - former]

Strategic lead of Newgon Organization. Yesmap Matrix Admin - former, Yesmap Fedi Admin - current.

Jim Burton (a pro-c) appeared to agree with the idea of using reporting mechanisms to attack the relationship of NNIA with its domain registrar, ideas that were discussed on the Yesmap Matrix server. This was in response to the above documented malicious conduct and apparent unwillingness of NNIA admin Lecter to leave post.

The following suspension of the ghetti domain above was pinned on Jim Burton by MAP Wiki, completely ignoring community consensus and the fact its suspension followed immediately after a 70,000-view YouTube video exposing pediverse.[12]

Violet Rose/Abby [FU, others]

Pro-c and plural system whose presence confused many as she seemed to exist only to sow division, supposedly "bullying" various individuals from different ends of the community. Made two accounts on the Yesmap (Newgon supported) Matrix server, appearing to "suck up" to key members, only to suddenly have unprovoked outbursts which resulted in bans.

Personality

This section includes less-extreme content intended to reflect broadly on the personalities of profiled individuals for whom malicious/and or illegal behavior is indicated.[13][14]

Jim Burton, i.e. "Newgon" (Jamal Ross, Mark Markison, Alfred Vincent, Analese Flangler, Peter Nordqvist, Andy Parkinson, Zara Degeneres, JohnHolt, Newgon Strategist and others) has also been included as juxtaposition against the "fascist" claims documented later on, and in his claims analysis.[15][16] Please note, he is "in character" in our screens, so an holistic reading is necessary.

Iris

Lecter

One further point of interest regards Lecter's personality, is his tendency to assume bad faith, or deliberately misread content to engineer talking points.[20]

Jim Burton

These screens document some bread-and-butter 2022 tweets of pro-c Jim Burton (as Jamal Ross, Mark Markison, Alfred Vincent, Analese Flangler, Newgon),[15] rather than PCMA's organized psychological operations and ragebaits:

It is likely others found his obsessive, day-to-day keyphrase-targeting, sealioning and corrections somewhat aggravating; especially the two above, who felt they should be doing, or had previously done visibility work on their own terms.

As per the section on "Newgon" below, and Lecter above, one stated aim of Jim Burton (since around 2022) has been to offend and agitate younger anti-contact MAPs in order to promote in them a political militancy.

Language/Thought-Policing

Lecter (a self-identified authoritarian) has an obsession with language-policing, sometimes supported by others, but never quite as vainly.[21] This has been realized in a series of bizarre threads. It is generally denied this is "thought policing", as the clique totally binarizes thoughts and behavior.

Separatism and Defederation

Lecter has at times signified the need to keep MAP spaces "deviant" and "degenerate", opposing attempts to expand the movement by capitalizing upon the considerable numbers of hebephiles who do not count themselves as members, or consider adoption of the stigma too risky. As a paraphilic hebephile, opposing political involvement of non-paraphilic hebephiles has been a balancing act for Lecter; something he appears to be fearful of, but something that might potentially sustain the community, thus hard to fully denounce.

Often, the rationale given for defederation of individuals and entire instances, while related to alleged harassment, in fact follows a pattern of Validity Policing. Illegal content aside, civil disagreement (individual bans), or uncivil individuals (instance bans) are the most common causes for defederation, suggesting control of discourse is more of a concern than civility, for NNIA.

Former NNIA members often claim to have experienced cult-like conditions. At one point around 2022/23, one such story appeared to be coming out every 2 months or so, as users transitioned to the more neutral-c instances of Youjo.love and Freak.university. These claims have been investigated by Newgon and found to be false, both by analysis of alleged "cult"/"grooming" activities and probabilistic methods.

"Newgon" conspiracy/anti-religious/anti-cult loading

PCMA server members have witnessed a number of unusual messages appearing on Fediverse instances (initially NNIA) since late 2021/2022. Usually, such messages mobilize the familiar language of anti-religion/anti-cult/sectarianism to denounce "Newgon" as a monolithic entity that has committed grave historical injustices; harassment, standing by while others are harmed, appeasement, "legitimizing malign voices", etc. These accusations are always made without support, appear to emanate from just a few accounts and bear no relation to the experiences of server members, nor their generally positive reception among MAPs on social media. One Jewish server admin has compared the vague, illogical and contradictory nature of this emotionalism to that of Antisemitic canards and gaslighting. For example, Jim Burton, Newgon's Strategic Lead, has been accused by MAP Wiki (NNIA) editors of knowing a person (Lilitha, aka ZeebDemon) so well, he was able to send a harassing card to their address, but at the same time knowing them so poorly he would have no way of even knowing their pronouns.

Much of this appears to span from a reaction-formation/cognitive dissonance of MAPs who find the content of Newgon challenging or confronting in some way or another.

As can be seen, the accusations are often embarrassingly off-point, attempting to depict "Newgon Members" (PCMA members) as dogmatists of some sort or another. Only the dogmas so accused are not shared by the server members.

Hivemind

In some cases, Pediverse users have supported neo-religious concepts, anti-logic and scientific movements that have been used to attack MAPs. Some anti-cultist ideas used aggressively against MAPs in the 1980s (such as the inextricably linked Dissociative Identity Disorder and Satanic Ritual Abuse) have seen a revival among fiction-loving MAPs themselves on Fediverse. While these are far from uniformly supported, and we will not fully document them here, it is hoped better education can combat disinformation within the community.

One particular incident involved the childlove.space (cl.s) instance (of which some involved held Yesmap Matrix accounts, leading to false links with "Newgon"). While the content was legally problematic in some non-host jurisdictions, it is somewhat revealing that other Fediverse members chose to focus on the right-wing ideology of but 2 or 3 of it's 1000+ members.

NNIA users have also engaged other users in a series of struggle-sessions over "bad" language or "ideologies" - Katie Cruz, a MAP activist from the 00s who has concerns about the public image of MAPs has been attacked as "assimilationist" on numerous occasions, invariably followed by dog-piling, ritualized disapproval and spitting-contests.

Paraphilia-maxxing

The identities below are predominantly anti-contact. While they may or may not be adopted in good-faith, there is a potential here (with the wrong kind of attention) to harm and undermine invalidated groups such as MAPs by falsely portraying them as inherently "violent". Said tactic was used deliberately against the original FST platform in 2022 (fake pro child rape accounts) and had previously been mentioned by a founder of B4U-ACT, Russell Dick.[27]

While this section below may look like a "freak show" or "rogues gallery", it intends to document how hostile parties could seek to misrepresent our community and attack the most vulnerable among us, something that has already happened[12] and will happen more in the future. Identities redacted where appropriate.

Of the above individuals, we are aware the identity "Dave" is known for being deliberately outrageous, and was ultimately censored by NNIA. He migrated to the Oddballs instance and others at a later date. For some more of his contributions, see the Oddballs analysis. Grooming-based identity was nevertheless defended full-throatedly by Lecter. Necryssa is a regular poster on NNIA, who we believe not to be an alt account. The origin of the others is unknown, many may be sock puppets, owing to the large number of plural systems on the instance.

"Pedosadists" are a complex topic, further complicated by the fact the anglicized version of the label has been used in campaigning by Anonymous. Between 2-10% of the wider population (50% using broader criteria) are assumed to be sadistic. Jim Burton has attested (in 2024) that he knows of a small number of MAPs who are also sadistic, but their views on self-identifying with terms such as "p(a)edosadist" vary widely.[28]

One argument in support of projecting extreme identities such as those described above, is that others unaware of the relatively low levels of psychopathy among MAPs, may be more inclined to believe they are hiding nothing. Extreme paraphilic identity might lend support to the idea that even extreme and violent impulses can be controlled, but could do harm by associating them with attraction to minors.[29]

Pride flags

Numerous self-identification labels and flags have appeared via NNIA and its associated Wikis, promoting identities that combine minor attraction with violent paraphilia, reifying states of mind we might identify in a dark history of childrens' nursery rhymes and fairy tales.[30]

While the combinations might seem suspicious or extreme in some way, readers soon become desensitized to the sheer range of identities on offer.[31] In 2023, even a child grooming flag featuring hard candy became available![32][33] It should be noted that all such identities are assumed to be anti-contact, so the extremity can ultimately be unlimited.

There have been attempts from outside of the paraphile community to coin pride-flags based on designs similar to the MAP Flag. See "rapesexual", for example.[34] The NNIA-associated Flag Wiki intersects biastophilia (attraction to rape) with attraction to minors in roughly half of the graphics mentioning biastophilia.[35]

The solution appears to be more realistic and responsible handling of intersectional identities, rather than exclusion of individuals from the community. The debate will doubtless intensify as the pediverse attracts more "outside attention".

Notes

Material on this page is unaltered, shared under fair-use and for the purpose of research. We also consider it a necessary retaliation against mass-scale non-consensual sharing of chatlogs by prominent NNIA members/administration, and apologize for any inconvenience caused.

If you are not a profiled individual within this collection, and wish for your social screen name to be removed from the screen caps, we are able to do this if you contact us directly.

  1. NNIA post by Lilitha"So... I got a birthday card today from an "Iris", today. But, it's not my birthday. Not even close. The card they sent was a screamer card that can't be shut off. And trying to access the battery compartment reveals it's full of glitter as a counter-tampering measure. In the card they call me a "paramisic bastard"... Gee. I wonder who THAT could be... 😒"
  2. Eientei.org's cache of a thread explaining Iris's involvement in doxxing, see also their live version, and fv.reveca.es
  3. Archive of long post in which Iris attempted to blame a malicious incident they are known for on "Newgon"
  4. The Hill: Russia’s parliament passes law banning ‘gay’ and ‘pedophilia’ propaganda
  5. Occupational change of location indicated (private information).
  6. Has written above-machine quality translations from English to Russian, for example
  7. 7.0 7.1 See these threads as an example of the type of doxxing/doxxing-enablement disputes Lecter gets involved in with others, and various vague accusations made against him:[1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15].
  8. E.g. [16], [17]
  9. e.g. Hyvas
  10. The Public Insight piece on NNIA
  11. I identify as a problem
  12. 12.0 12.1 FS Tube: Deadwing Dork's Video in 2024 re. Pediverse and the Ezra Dox - startpoint of the Oddballs.online instance. Original was here, but removed for guideline violation. Password protected for known researchers only. Narrative in claims analysis. See also, follow-up video (no password required).
  13. Lecter's early social media archives reveal a person more concerned with the real-life situation of MAPs, and less in thrall of what he calls "aberrosexual" ideology and identity politics. See Twitter [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23]. Also ran Twitter accounts Blood_seeds, Baron_Deer, go_to_tumblr, FemmeDiscordant.
  14. It is possible Lecter and Iris bonded over their hatred of animals, underpinning what was to become their open celebration of "Zoosadism Pride" on NNIA. In 2018, Lecter was already posting memes describing his indifference to animal cruelty on Deviantart, as akhnaton-ii. On 8 September 2023, 03:27 Lecter renamed user Chronic to Iris ‎on MAP Wiki. For more profiling of Iris, see its curiouscat, NNIA and Twitter archives
  15. 15.0 15.1 Jamal Ross Archive 1 and Jamal Ross Archive 2. For Web Archive, [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30]. Unfortunately the earlier accounts (going back to Aug 2021) are not available in archive form, but they involved similar agitation against misinterpretation of the term "MAP" and misconceptions about the MAP Flag, MAP History, etc. The following archives contain a few examples of Jim's interactions (as Jamal) with Lecter, his adjacents (seen as @go_to_tumblr) and some others: [31], [32], [33], [34], [35], [36], [37], [38]. This type of agitation appears to have led to a campaign to present "Newgon" as "fascist-adjacent" via a "MAP Wiki" article.
  16. Archive of Jim's Youjo account
  17. Iris on Frans Gieles
  18. Comrade Lecter on Tumblr
  19. 19.0 19.1 On The Anti-c Youth Liberationist. Lecter argues that unlike other ageist statutes, AoC Laws can be maintained as their job is to regulate "older persons’ actions that target the youth". His earlier (probably accurate, or understated) contention that 1/3rd of molesters are children is ignored, with an appeal for exceptions to the rule.
  20. Example of bad-faith assumption and response
  21. Extra-ordinary thread in which an Iris alt deep-critiques a Newgon meme that intended to redeploy alt-right language against... antis and the alt-right. See also critique.
  22. Gooners, i.e. fetishists who actually practice what NNIA members preach. Most such individuals would be deemed "problematic" or "bigoted"; their presence and lewd fantasies would instigate conflicts.
  23. The truth about minor-attracted people - Elliot Porter
  24. NNIA: About
  25. JohnHolt (Jim Burton): I agree in so far as [...] - BoyChat post in which Jim Burton identifies attacks on Transgender identity, see also Transgender and Queer Theory, Moral Capture, his identification of transphobic attacks by a civil society organization.
  26. Such is the inherent risk of early Fediverse communities, since they mix people seeking safe spaces with edgelords and ask them to make collective decisions to platform or deplatform each other.
  27. AFP interview with R Dick
  28. Jim Burton, 18 Jul 2024: "I am reliably informed one self-identified pedosadist has been accepted as moderator at a private MAP Forum; it appears they are not always highly expressive about this aspect of their personality, and do not act on it. Another sadistic MAP I am aware of agrees that there is really no point using terminology such as "pedosadist", as it will only inflame existing stereotypes. The most vocal MAPs on this topic, I actually doubt are pedo or nepio-sadists themselves, and are using the idea of "pedo/nepiosadist pride" as a crutch for their edgy political agendas, with little thought given to the potential fallout."
  29. Kidfucker's Charter
  30. Burning, Starving and Maiming: Nursery Rhymes Without Happily Ever Afters, 10 Disturbing Nursery Rhyme Origin Stories to Celebrate Nursery Rhyme Week
  31. Zoosadist Pride Flag. Of note is the fact that the wiki has as many flags for Zoosadists as it does Zoosexuals
  32. Various flags: Aptomap, Apto, Necro MAP, Necropedozoo
  33. Flags for Over 1000 paraphilias, designed by NNIA members, including the "apto" (grooming) flags featuring hard candy.
  34. Rapesexual Chan Flag
  35. Search for "biasto" on Paraphilia Flags Wiki